Clear 73°5 Day Forecast
News Search

Advanced search
go
Home
Shop Now!
Classifieds
Jobs
Auto
Real Estate
Shopping
Place An Ad
News
Regional NewsPolice/CourtsBusinessBlog CentralObituariesWeatherAP - The WireTop Read StoriesMost Talked About
Sports
Life
Opinion
Classifieds
Las Noticias
Photo Galleries
People & Events
About Us
Other Publications
Entertainment
Doorways
Subscriptions
Fun and Games
Consumer Guide
Personal Finance
Lifestyles
USA Weekend
Special Section
Entertainment
Movies
TV
Crosswords
Horoscope
Fun & Games
Site Tools
Yellow Pages
Photo Galleries
Services
Subscribe
Photo Reprints
About Us
Daily Freeman Jobs
Home : News : News : Top Stories
Top Stories
Paterson blocks study comparing public, private rec sites
By Ariel Zangla, Freeman staff
09/06/2008
email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendly
GOV. DAVID Paterson has vetoed legislation hat would have created an independent panel to evaluate whether state-owned recreation facilities in New York have an unfair advantage over private operations.

The legislation called for a blue-ribbon commission to examine whether state-owned golfing, skiing and camping facilities, among others, had the upper hand over the private counterparts.

The bill, favored by the Greene County Legislature, was approved unanimously by the state Senate and 134-2 by the Assembly.

Greene County lawmakers supported the commission because they believe the state-owned Belleayre Mountain Ski Center in the Ulster County town of Shandaken provides unfair competition to the privately owned Hunter and Windham ski centers in Greene.

Operations such as Belleayre have the edge, Greene County leaders said, because they can charge less than their private counterparts without worrying about losing money, Any shortfall will be made up by the state.

State Sen. James Seward, the bill's sponsor, said in a prepared statement on Friday that he was "disappointed by the governor's veto."

"Public facilities like state ski areas or golf courses are under no obligation to make a profit, pay workers' compensation or unemployment insurance, and the bill called for a study - a study - to look at whether public facilities have an unfair edge," said Seward, R-Milford.

Greene Legislature Chairman Wayne Speenburgh could not be reached for comment on Friday.

Seward said public facilities, because they are funded by taxpayers, can buy equipment using state contracts, pay no sales taxes and be exempt from state health and environmental regulations that raise costs for private entities.

"In essence, taxpayers subsidize lower costs for public facilities, which then compete with private operations paying taxes, workers' comp and trying to at least break even," the senator said.

Seward also said the state must look at the effect of government competition on businesses paying property taxes, creating jobs and supporting schools.

In a resolution supporting the Senate bill, Greene County lawmakers said Belleayre, which is run by the state Department of Environmental Conservation, "continues to operate by giving away thousands of complimentary lift tickets and specially priced ski days, all of which factor into Belleayre continually operating at a deficit and are uncommon practices that are not conducive to running a profitable ski resort."

The giveaways and discounts have led to increased skier visits at Belleayre at the expense of Hunter and Windham, the county resolution stated.

Besides backing the Senate bill, Greene County lawmakers earlier this year asked the state to audit Belleayre's finances. The state refused.


©Daily Freeman 2010

Reader Comments
 Submit your own comment!
Added: Saturday September 06, 2008 at 10:27 AM EST
May be it is a can of worms best left unopened
pat guido, hyde park, NY
Added: Saturday September 06, 2008 at 07:48 AM EST
Not in touch?
Someone must not have told him, this bill was passed unanymously in the Senate and overwhelmingly by the Assembly. Did someone explain to him what overturning a veto means, and what it says about the executive who did the vetoing? Can you say, not in touch?
Joe Bubel, Kingston, NY
View All 3 Comments »

email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendlyTop
Advertisement

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement. Please read our Privacy Policy
©2007 Daily Freeman - a Journal Register Property. All Rights reserved.

Interested in a career with Journal Register Company? Click here.
Journal Register

MidHudsonCentral.com is your local connection to newspaper websites in the Mid-Hudson Region.